[asterisk-users] Hardware suggestions for 8-10 lines in the UK

Stephen Bosch posting at vodacomm.ca
Thu Apr 19 08:15:22 MST 2007


Hi, Ed:

Ed W wrote:
> Agreed.  My experience is that quality is higher on Voip than it is via
> a TDM400p.  However, my experience hasn't been that VoiP is as reliable
> as copper lines and so unless you can tolerate the odd outage once per
> month or two then you might want to stick to copper for the main
> carrier?  Does this match with the experience from others?

Oh, yes. When I read Chris' message I thought -- "good thing he's still
got some PSTN lines." I would never, ever suggest that anybody go all
VoIP. The reliability is a long way from being where it needs to be. As
an adjunct, it's great, but I'd never replace PSTN service across the board.

Obviously I can't speak for BT and the UK circumstance, but once the
card a TDM400P card is tuned properly (which, I admit, can take some
effort), the call quality is excellent. The biggest hurdle, of course,
is echo, and SIP calls aren't (normally) afflicted with that because the
echo cancellation is present along the entire path.

-Stephen-



More information about the asterisk-users mailing list