[asterisk-dev] Viva Chan_Sip, may it rest in peace

Olle E. Johansson oej at edvina.net
Wed Oct 5 04:42:01 CDT 2016


Hi!

From my perspective I know that maintaining a SIP stack requires *A LOT* of effort, so I understand that a project can’t maintain two of them.

I suggest that a working group is created for the transition and that the first task is to compare the functionality. 
Last time I checked the functionality *I need* (but maybe not everyone else) was non-existing in PJSIP so I could not use it.
It may have changed since then.

I think the goal has to be to gradually phase out the ugly code in chan_sip and celebrate the day it’s gone, but
make sure we don’t leave functionality (and users) behind and have good guidelines for the transition.

I still think we should totally rewrite how chan_pjsip is configured. That concept is very far away from other SIP implementations.
But that’s my personal opinion from a small cold corner of the world, using Asterisk in non-PBX ways as large scale media 
and feature servers.

Executive summary: Create a working group that maintains the feature gap, makes sure it’s going away and also makes sure
that we have enough material that explains the gold that hides in chan_pjsip!

/O


More information about the asterisk-dev mailing list