[asterisk-dev] Asterisk pjsip support all media_encryption no/dtls/sdes for incoming request

[Joshua Colp]

Henry Lin wrote:
>
> Hi Joshua,
>
> Thanks for your tips.
>
> For the OUTGOING part, there is no problem. we already did as you said (
> use inherited endpoints).
>
> For INCOMING part, you said:
>
> 1.  media_encryption_optimistic is created for SDES, which can supports
> both sdes and no-encryption in the same config endpoints.
>      and our test for DTLS also works but is a side effect.
>
> 2. a new param of media_encryption = "optional" is possible to do in the
> code, which can supports SDES/DTLS/NO-ENCRYPTION at the same config
> endpoint for incoming ( ex: caller ).
>
>
> So in your opinion:
>
> would it be better to integrate media_encryption = "optional" with
> media_encryption_optimistic = true ? or just leave them separated?

I'd just leave them separated, I'm not a huge fan of repurposing 
optimistic away from its original purpose and changing the requirements 
of it.

>
> since they are trying to solve the same problem --- support webrtc
> clients but also have backward-compatibility to the huge amount of
> old-school devices
>
> media_encryption = "optional" implies media_encryption_optimistic = true.
>
>
> by the way,
> Is there anyone already implement this, or opened an issue tracker that
> can be patched ?

I know of noone who has done this or any patch.

-- 
Joshua Colp
Digium, Inc. | Senior Software Developer
445 Jan Davis Drive NW - Huntsville, AL 35806 - US
Check us out at: www.digium.com & www.asterisk.org