[asterisk-users] One Way Audio
Tim King
tim at compnetwork.net
Thu Mar 10 10:00:34 CST 2011
Still not working now that audio is restored jitter makes it inaudible? I
am ready to move this to commercial if someone can tell me how I need to pay
for support,
Thanks
Tim
On Thu, Mar 10, 2011 at 10:19 AM, Tim King <tim at compnetwork.net> wrote:
> It looks like the issue was my provider enforcing a codec translation that
> was not working.
>
>
> On Thu, Mar 10, 2011 at 9:21 AM, Satish Patel <satish_lx at hotmail.com>wrote:
>
>> Also it could be the routing issue as well.
>>
>> --
>> Sent from my iPhone
>>
>> On Mar 9, 2011, at 7:43 PM, Duncan Turnbull <duncan at e-simple.co.nz>
>> wrote:
>>
>> So that suggests audio is flowing as follows in a unidirectional manner
>>
>> 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 >
>> 209.216.2.203.60362
>>
>>
>> Somewhere near the end this pops up which is slightly different, I am
>> guessing 74.204.4.5 is your asterisk box
>>
>> 19:18:36.389548 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 174.133.195.194.18364: UDP, length
>> 172
>>
>> I am not sure why this is happening or if its still part of the same
>> conversation
>>
>> Overall it looks a bit like the asterisk box thinks it needs to send rtp
>> to a different location than perhaps its meant to i.e. its asymmetric - you
>> can check the sdp in the sip invite to see where media is expected to be
>> sent to
>>
>> There is no rtp coming back from 209.216.2.203 so possibly this is device
>> that isn't meant to be part of the conversation and either doesn't exist or
>> is not expecting anything and thus not responding
>>
>> What are the addresses of the devices in this conversation? so that you
>> can match the traffic to device
>>
>> Cheers Duncan
>>
>> On 10/03/2011, at 1:20 PM, Tim King wrote:
>>
>> It looks like this:
>> 19:18:34.782016 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.789527 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.802064 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.809757 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.821855 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.829598 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.842015 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.849764 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.861902 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.869568 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.881882 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.889739 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.901882 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.909612 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.921984 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.929664 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.941855 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.949589 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.962003 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.969592 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.981851 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:34.989543 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.002006 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.009973 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.022008 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.029539 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.042071 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.049561 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.062008 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.069612 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.081986 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.089519 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.101918 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.109722 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.122021 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.129590 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.141878 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.149709 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.161886 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.169561 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.181879 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.189710 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.201965 IP 199.173.66.22.53103 > 74.204.4.5.11733: UDP, length 60
>> 19:18:35.201974 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.209552 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.221898 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.229625 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.241894 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.249566 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.261999 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.269701 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.281873 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.289521 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.301898 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.309599 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.322057 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.329595 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.341889 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.349555 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.361905 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.369599 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.381961 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.389534 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.401947 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.409753 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.421901 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.429605 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.441889 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.449714 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.462001 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.469738 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.481970 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.489713 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.501916 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.509584 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.521932 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.529633 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.541882 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.549514 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.561905 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.569629 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.581945 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.589535 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.601933 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.609748 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.621928 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.629542 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.641918 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.649552 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.662041 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.669660 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.681932 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.689593 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.702007 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.709739 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.721927 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.729584 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.741928 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.749724 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.761954 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.769703 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.782063 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.789751 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.802062 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.809632 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.821945 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.829662 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.842021 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.849555 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.862007 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.869574 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.881959 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.889585 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.902030 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.909697 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.922073 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.929518 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.941925 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.949511 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.962033 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.969638 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.982057 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:35.989576 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.002025 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.009782 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.021935 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.029591 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.041944 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.049761 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.061939 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.069719 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.082035 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.089685 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.102040 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.109568 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.122062 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.129698 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.142063 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.149589 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.162024 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.169637 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.181959 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.189543 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.202018 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.202027 IP 199.173.66.22.53103 > 74.204.4.5.11733: UDP, length 60
>> 19:18:36.209751 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.222036 IP 199.173.66.22.53102 > 74.204.4.5.11732: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.229544 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.249522 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.269699 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.289586 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.309528 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.329544 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.349672 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.369715 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 209.216.2.203.60362: UDP, length 172
>> 19:18:36.389548 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 174.133.195.194.18364: UDP, length
>> 172
>> 19:18:36.409578 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 174.133.195.194.18364: UDP, length
>> 172
>> 19:18:36.429550 IP 74.204.4.5.11732 > 174.133.195.194.18364: UDP, length
>> 172
>>
>>
>> On Wed, Mar 9, 2011 at 7:01 PM, Duncan Turnbull < <duncan at e-simple.co.nz>
>> duncan at e-simple.co.nz> wrote:
>>
>>> Can you do a tcpdump to look at the rtp streams on your box and check
>>> they are both generating and aiming at the right places
>>>
>>> IAX will have no issue with NAT/firewall but SIP / RTP can.
>>>
>>> tcpdump -nn udp and portrange 10000-20000
>>> (pick your portrange if its operating on something else)
>>>
>>> Should show you mad lines of rtp going backwards and forwards (like
>>> below) when there is a conversation in place. If you can see it being sent
>>> from the asterisk box but not heard by the client then either try a
>>> different client, or something is blocking the return leg to your client
>>>
>>> 13:00:21.309139 IP 192.168.63.83.16450 > 192.168.63.30.13902: UDP, length
>>> 172
>>> 13:00:21.328703 IP 192.168.63.83.16450 > 192.168.63.30.13902: UDP, length
>>> 172
>>> 13:00:21.348572 IP 192.168.63.83.16450 > 192.168.63.30.13902: UDP, length
>>> 172
>>> 13:00:21.369096 IP 192.168.63.83.16450 > 192.168.63.30.13902: UDP, length
>>> 172
>>> 13:00:21.388572 IP 192.168.63.83.16450 > 192.168.63.30.13902: UDP, length
>>> 172
>>>
>>> Cheers Duncan
>>>
>>> On 10/03/2011, at 12:26 PM, Tim King wrote:
>>>
>>> Thank you I have also tried those settings. The main thing is coming from
>>> my voip provider all I am doing is bridging the calls to two other devices
>>> (1 trixbox and 1 digium aa50) via IAX trunks. Both devices are answering
>>> with an IVR and when I call in I can not hear the IVR. However if I call
>>> directly to a SIP client the person answering the SIP phone can hear me but
>>> I can not hear them at all. Its definately not a NAT issue which is what
>>> makes it even more confusing. When the call is in place a sip show channels
>>> shows me both lefs of the call and they are both using either alaw or ulaw
>>> so it should not be a codec translation issue either.
>>>
>>> On Wed, Mar 9, 2011 at 6:19 PM, Satish Patel < <satish_lx at hotmail.com>
>>> satish_lx at hotmail.com> wrote:
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> --
>>> _____________________________________________________________________
>>> -- Bandwidth and Colocation Provided by <http://www.api-digital.com/>
>>> http://www.api-digital.com --
>>> New to Asterisk? Join us for a live introductory webinar every Thurs:
>>> <http://www.asterisk.org/hello>
>>> http://www.asterisk.org/hello
>>>
>>> asterisk-users mailing list
>>> To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit:
>>> <http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users>
>>> http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
>>>
>>
>>
>> --
>> _____________________________________________________________________
>> -- Bandwidth and Colocation Provided by http://www.api-digital.com --
>> New to Asterisk? Join us for a live introductory webinar every Thurs:
>> <http://www.asterisk.org/hello>
>> http://www.asterisk.org/hello
>>
>> asterisk-users mailing list
>> To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit:
>> <http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users>
>> http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users
>>
>>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.digium.com/pipermail/asterisk-users/attachments/20110310/0f9fef0c/attachment-0001.htm>
More information about the asterisk-users
mailing list