[asterisk-r2] Porque no contestan

Anton Krall antonkrall at gmail.com
Mon Mar 1 16:03:20 CST 2010


Well, unfortunately Ive searched the list and all I could find was that you
need to put more time on the fwd_safety_timeout setting in r2proto.conf
(which I assume is on /usr/local/etc, where the compiler put it) but in this
particular case, it is not help so I dont know where else to turn but here,
where the tech support for r2 is... Ive already sent the call traces that
are usually required for anyone to take a look at them and maybe some expert
eyes could find a problem in them... So what else can I do Moises, you tell
me...



From: Moises Silva <moises.silva at gmail.com>
Reply-To: <asterisk-r2 at lists.digium.com>
Date: Mon, 1 Mar 2010 16:22:46 -0500
To: <asterisk-r2 at lists.digium.com>
Subject: Re: [asterisk-r2] Porque no contestan

I am implying they are not interesting to me at this point of the time. At
least not enough to spend my spare time on it.

On Mon, Mar 1, 2010 at 4:19 PM, Anton Krall <antonkrall at gmail.com> wrote:
> Moises are you implying that the fwd safety timeouts that are preventing the
> completion of long distance calls using R2 is not "interesting"?
> 
> 
> 
> From: Moises Silva <moises.silva at gmail.com>
> Reply-To: <asterisk-r2 at lists.digium.com>
> Date: Mon, 1 Mar 2010 16:07:50 -0500
> To: <asterisk-r2 at lists.digium.com>
> Subject: Re: [asterisk-r2] Porque no contestan
> 
> Anton, please keep the conversation in the asterisk-r2 list. If nobody
> answers there, including me, is either because people is too busy or they
> just don't know. In my case, I am quite busy these days and I am trying to
> keep a distance from e-mail and mailing lists in particular and just reply
> to issues that I consider interesting or that have not been discussed
> before.
> 
> On Mon, Mar 1, 2010 at 2:06 PM, Anton Krall <akrall at intruder.mx> wrote:
>> Moises, sabes que puede estar pasando, esta pasando con 2 e1 de telmex en
>> lugares diferentes... Es cosa de openr2 y configuracion o es cosa de telmex?
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> ________________________________________________________________
>> Anton Krall
> 
>> From: Anton Krall <antonkrall at gmail.com>
>> Date: Thu, 25 Feb 2010 18:55:53 -0600
>> To: <asterisk-r2 at lists.digium.com>
>> Conversation: [asterisk-r2] Fwd safety timeouts
>> Subject: Re: [asterisk-r2] Fwd safety timeouts
>> 
>> My r2proto.conf file is located in /usr/local/etc (thats where the make put
>> it, is that ok)? And inside it has fwd_timeout at 30000... Which sould be
>> enough I think...
>> 
>> Can anybody see something wrong from the traces I posted?
>> 
>> What do you think Moy?
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> From: Shazaum <shazaum at gmail.com>
>> Reply-To: <asterisk-r2 at lists.digium.com>
>> Date: Thu, 25 Feb 2010 19:10:30 -0300
>> To: <asterisk-r2 at lists.digium.com>
>> Subject: Re: [asterisk-r2] Fwd safety timeouts
>> 
>> I do not understand very well, but what is the timeout in conf?
>> 
>> 
>> Renato dos Santos
>> renato at opens.com.br
>> OpenS Tecnologia Ltda
>> Rua Padre Marcelino Champagnat, 236
>> Jardim Atlântico - Florianópolis - SC - Brasil
>> +55 (48) 3954-8000
>> http://www.opens.com.br
>> shazaum.wordpress.com <http://shazaum.wordpress.com>
>> <http://shazaum.wordpress.com>
>> <http://shazaum.wordpress.com>
>> 
>> 
>> On 25 February 2010 16:36, Anton Krall <antonkrall at gmail.com> wrote:
>>> Moises? Any ideas?
>>> 
>>> -----
>>> 
>>> Guys, Im getting FWD safety timeouts when calling LD from Mexico to Spain.
>>> 
>>> This is what the call trace shows on my side
>>> 
>>> 12:44:12:679] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Call started at Tue Feb 23
>>> 12:44:12 2010 on chan 25
>>> [12:44:12:679] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - CAS Tx >> [SEIZE] 0x00
>>> [12:44:12:679] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - CAS Raw Tx >> 0x01
>>> [12:44:12:721] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Bits changed from 0x08 to 0x0C
>>> [12:44:12:721] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - CAS Rx << [SEIZE ACK] 0x0C
>>> [12:44:12:721] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 2
>>> [12:44:12:721] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - timer id 2 found, cancelling
>>> it now
>>> [12:44:12:721] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Sending DNIS digit 0
>>> [12:44:12:721] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 0 [ON]
>>> [12:44:12:818] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:12:818] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:12:818] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> [12:44:12:818] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 0 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:12:898] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:12:898] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Sending DNIS digit 0
>>> [12:44:12:898] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 0 [ON]
>>> [12:44:12:898] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Group A DNIS request handled
>>> [12:44:12:958] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:12:958] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:12:958] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> [12:44:12:958] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 0 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:018] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:018] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Sending DNIS digit 3
>>> [12:44:13:018] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 3 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:018] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Group A DNIS request handled
>>> [12:44:13:078] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:078] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:078] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:078] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 3 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:138] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:138] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Sending DNIS digit 4
>>> [12:44:13:138] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 4 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:138] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Group A DNIS request handled
>>> [12:44:13:198] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:198] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:198] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:198] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 4 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:258] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:258] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Sending DNIS digit 9
>>> [12:44:13:258] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 9 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:258] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Group A DNIS request handled
>>> [12:44:13:318] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:318] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:318] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:318] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 9 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:378] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:378] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Sending DNIS digit 4
>>> [12:44:13:378] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 4 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:378] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Group A DNIS request handled
>>> [12:44:13:438] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:438] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:438] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:438] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 4 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:518] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:518] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Sending DNIS digit 6
>>> [12:44:13:518] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 6 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:518] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Group A DNIS request handled
>>> [12:44:13:578] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:578] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:578] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:578] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 6 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:638] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:638] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Sending DNIS digit 7
>>> [12:44:13:638] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 7 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:638] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Group A DNIS request handled
>>> [12:44:13:718] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:718] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:718] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:718] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 7 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:798] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:798] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Sending DNIS digit 1
>>> [12:44:13:798] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:798] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Group A DNIS request handled
>>> [12:44:13:858] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:858] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:858] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:858] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:918] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:13:918] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Sending DNIS digit 9
>>> [12:44:13:918] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 9 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:918] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Group A DNIS request handled
>>> [12:44:13:998] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:13:998] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:998] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> [12:44:13:998] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 9 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:14:058] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:14:058] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Sending DNIS digit 5
>>> [12:44:14:058] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 5 [ON]
>>> [12:44:14:058] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Group A DNIS request handled
>>> [12:44:14:098] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:14:098] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:14:098] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> [12:44:14:098] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 5 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:14:179] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:14:179] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Sending DNIS digit 0
>>> [12:44:14:179] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 0 [ON]
>>> [12:44:14:179] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Group A DNIS request handled
>>> [12:44:14:238] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:14:238] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:14:238] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> [12:44:14:238] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 0 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:14:298] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:14:298] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Sending DNIS digit 9
>>> [12:44:14:298] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 9 [ON]
>>> [12:44:14:298] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Group A DNIS request handled
>>> [12:44:14:358] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [ON]
>>> [12:44:14:358] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:14:358] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> [12:44:14:358] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Tx >> 9 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:14:418] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - MF Rx << 1 [OFF]
>>> [12:44:14:418] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - No more DNIS. Doing nothing,
>>> waiting for timeout.
>>> [12:44:14:418] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Group A DNIS request handled
>>> [12:44:24:418] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 3
>>> [12:44:24:418] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - timer id 3 found, cancelling
>>> it now
>>> [12:44:24:418] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - calling timer callback
>>> [12:44:24:418] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Protocol error. Reason =
>>> Forward Safety Timeout, R2 State = Seize ACK Received, MF state = Waiting
>>> Far End Time
>>> out, MF Group = Forward Group I, CAS = 0x0C
>>> DNIS = 0034946719509, ANI = 290, MF = 0x20
>>> [12:44:24:418] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Attempting to cancel timer
>>> timer 0
>>> [12:44:24:418] [Thread: 21314464] [Chan 25] - Cannot cancel timer 0
>>> 
>>> 
>>> And this is what Telmex is saying... Maybe its something related to timeout
>>> config on r2proto?
>>> 
>>> WO     IZTAC/64-A/04-00  AT-16          TIME 100223 1248  PAGE    1
>>> RECORDING OF TELEPHONY SIGNALS RECORDED RESULTS
>>> RI               :  0
>>> TEST OBJECT       : BL3DM-793
>>> ROUTE            : -
>>> GROUP NUMBER      : 5555196940
>>> SUBROUTE         : B-0
>>> CONNECTED ROUTE   : CR
>>> GLOBAL STATE      : IDLE
>>> START TIME       : 1247
>>> FIRST SIGNAL TIME : 124742
>>> 
>>> TIME  TDIFF  SIGNAL                  DIR BITS      RP ST. DEVICE
>>> 
>>> 39770 0000000                         S   0000 1001 H'35   BL3DM-793
>>> 39770 0000000                         R  0000 1001 H'35   BL3DM-793
>>> 42000 0002230                         R   0000 1000 H'35   BL3DM-793
>>> 42020 0000020                         R   0000 1000 H'4    BL3DM-793
>>> 42020 0000000 SEIZURE ACKN.           S   0000 1011 H'4    BL3DM-793
>>> 42090 0000070 GROUP I 10              R   0000 1010 H'2    CSRLM-27
>>> 42090 0000000 A1                      S   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 57790 0000180 GROUP I 10              R   0000 1010 H'3    CSRLM-70
>>>  cdmxdfizds1             channel: metm2
>>> 42230 0000140 GROUP I 10              R   0000 1010 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 42230 0000000 A1                      S   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 42350 0000120 GROUP I 3               R   0000 0011 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 42350 0000000 A1                      S   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 42470 0000120 GROUP I 4               R   0000 0100 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 42470 0000000 A1                      S   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 42590 0000120 GROUP I 9               R   0000 1001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 42590 0000000 A1                      S   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 42720 0000130 GROUP I 4               R   0000 0100 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 42720 0000000 A1                      S   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 42840 0000120 GROUP I 6               R   0000 0110 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 42840 0000000 A1                      S   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 42970 0000130 GROUP I 7               R   0000 0111 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 42970 0000000 A1                      S   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 43090 0000120 GROUP I 1               R   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 43090 0000000 A1                      S   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 43220 0000130 GROUP I 9               R   0000 1001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 43220 0000000 A1                      S   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 43340 0000120 GROUP I 5               R   0000 0101 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 43340 0000000 A1                      S   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 43470 0000130 GROUP I 10              R   0000 1010 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 43470 0000000 A1                      S   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 43600 0000130 GROUP I 9               R   0000 1001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 43600 0000000 A1                      S   0000 0001 H'3    CSRLM-27
>>> 53700 0010100                         R   0000 1001 H'4    BL3DM-793
>>> 53730 0000030                         R   0000 1001 H'1A   BL3DM-793
>>> 53730 0000000 RELEASE GUARD           S   0000 1001 H'1A   BL3DM-793
>>> 53980 0000250                         R   0000 1001 H'35   BL3DM-793
>>> 53980 0000000 IDLE                    S   0000 1001 H'35   BL3DM-793
>>> 
>>> Can you help?
>>> 
>>> 
>>> 
>>> --
>>> _____________________________________________________________________
>>> -- Bandwidth and Colocation Provided by http://www.api-digital.com --
>>> 
>>> asterisk-r2 mailing list
>>> To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit:
>>>    http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-r2
>> 
>> 
>> 
>> --
>> _____________________________________________________________________
>> -- Bandwidth and Colocation Provided by http://www.api-digital.com --
>> 
>> asterisk-r2 mailing list
>> To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit:
>>    http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-r2
>> 
>> ------ End of Forwarded Message
>> 
> 
> 
> 
> --
> Moises Silva
> Senior Software Engineer
> Sangoma Technologies Inc. | 50 McIntosh Drive, Suite 120, Markham ON L3R 9T3
> Canada
> t. 1 905 474 1990 x 128 | e. moy at sangoma.com
> 
> 
> 
> --
> _____________________________________________________________________
> -- Bandwidth and Colocation Provided by http://www.api-digital.com --
> 
> asterisk-r2 mailing list
> To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit:
>    http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-r2



-- 
Moises Silva
Senior Software Engineer
Sangoma Technologies Inc. | 50 McIntosh Drive, Suite 120, Markham ON L3R 9T3
Canada
t. 1 905 474 1990 x 128 | e. moy at sangoma.com


-- 
_____________________________________________________________________
-- Bandwidth and Colocation Provided by http://www.api-digital.com --

asterisk-r2 mailing list
To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit:
   http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-r2





More information about the asterisk-r2 mailing list