[asterisk-dev] IAX and SIP manager events inconsistency?

[Wojtek Kaniewski]

Hi,

I'm trying to do some monitoring of IAX and SIP registration, but 
manager events seem to be inconsistent. Each one contains different 
information, so it's hard for me to find out to which provider the event 
applies.

                               | Username |     Domain
------------------------------+----------+---------------
SIP Registration Success [1]  |    no    | yes, hostname
SIP Registration Failure [2]  |    yes   | yes, hostname
IAX2 Registration Success [3] |    no    |   yes, IP
IAX2 Registration Failure [4] |    yes   |      no

I don't understand why IAX events don't send hostname. Is this a result 
of a conscious decision? Or maybe it would be okay if I wrote a patch to 
unify all events and send username plus hostname (not IP)?

Regards,
Wojtek

[1] Channel: SIP
     Domain: localhost
     Status: Registered

[2] Channel: SIP
     Username: johndoe
     Domain: localhost
     Status: Unregistered

[3] Channel: IAX2
     Domain: 127.0.0.1
     Status: Registered

[4] Channel: IAX2
     Username: johndoe
     Status: Rejected
     Cause: Whatever