[asterisk-bugs] [JIRA] (ASTERISK-30221) Channel masquerades screw up groups
Mark Murawski (JIRA)
noreply at issues.asterisk.org
Mon Sep 12 08:42:09 CDT 2022
[ https://issues.asterisk.org/jira/browse/ASTERISK-30221?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=260148#comment-260148 ]
Mark Murawski commented on ASTERISK-30221:
------------------------------------------
Wait... are you saying you reported an issue against unmerged code?
Regarding: UPDATE - POC test with base 18.14.0 shows no issue, so likely related to func_groupcount.c changes
Have you tried against all LTS branches?
> Channel masquerades screw up groups
> -----------------------------------
>
> Key: ASTERISK-30221
> URL: https://issues.asterisk.org/jira/browse/ASTERISK-30221
> Project: Asterisk
> Issue Type: Bug
> Security Level: None
> Components: Core/Bridging, Functions/func_groupcount
> Affects Versions: 18.14.0
> Reporter: N A
> Severity: Major
>
> RELATED to: ASTERISK-30210
> So circling back to the weird thing with masquerades:
> I don't think it has anything to do with optimizations, per se, I think it's the masquerade itself. For some reason, it seems to consistently screw up groups.
> Here is an example of a system caught red handed where, after a masquerade occurs, suddenly all of the groups on all channels on the system suddenly become assigned to a *SINGLE* channel. This includes the bizarre scenario of also having the same group assignment twice on the same channel, such that GROUP_COUNT returns 2 even those there is only one channel in the group. This has the effect afterwards of putting the channel into an infinite loop due to dialplan logic that expects 2 channels.
> None of this happened prior to upgrading from 18.9.0 to 18.14.0, so a regression is possible but I'm not yet positive either. It also seems weird that masquerades would be broken in such a a fundamental way.
> The group screwing up seems to vary: the example in ASTERISK-30210 simply made all the groups disappear, in this case they all hop onto a single channel even from other channels that still exist (as well as groups that no longer do so).
> Note also that this system includes the group variables patch on Gerrit and testing without that is difficult/impossible. The bug could very well be there too, though that doesn't explain why it's only triggered by masquerades.
> UPDATE - POC test with base 18.14.0 shows no issue, so likely related to func_groupcount.c changes
> Example:
> {noformat}
> voip*CLI> group show channels
> Channel Group Category
> PJSIP/ATAxGrandstream1-00000040 PJSIP/ATAxGrandstream1 deviceinuse
> PJSIP/ATAxGrandstream1-00000040 1 lineinuse
> PJSIP/ATAxGrandstream1-00000040 1 oe
> PJSIP/ATAxGrandstream1-00000040 1 oeall
> Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;2 1 oeall
> Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;2 1 lineinuseoutboundunanswered
> Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;2 1 bridgedcalls
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 looparound_231004tone side
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 looparound_231004 looparound
> 9 active channels
> ...
> [2022-09-11 19:13:13] -- Executing [s at loop:10] Bridge("Local/2310042 at route-0000011e;2", "Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2") in new stack
> [2022-09-11 19:13:13] -- Local/2310042 at route-0000011e;1 answered Local/92310042 at originate-local-0000011c;2
> [2022-09-11 19:13:13] -- Local/92310042 at originate-local-0000011c;1 answered Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:13] -- Local/92310042 at originate-local-0000011c;1 Internal Gosub(outgoing-ring-answer,s,1) start
> [2022-09-11 19:13:13] -- Executing [s at outgoing-ring-answer:1] ASTREXOutgoingAnswer("Local/92310042 at originate-local-0000011c;1", "") in new stack
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] -- Channel Local/2310042 at route-0000011e;1 joined 'simple_bridge' basic-bridge <494a5de1-aac8-46f6-a561-f199d443704a>
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] -- Executing [s at outgoing-ring-answer:2] Return("Local/92310042 at originate-local-0000011c;1", "") in new stack
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] -- Channel Local/92310042 at originate-local-0000011c;2 joined 'simple_bridge' basic-bridge <494a5de1-aac8-46f6-a561-f199d443704a>
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] == Spawn extension (originate-local, , 1) exited non-zero on 'Local/92310042 at originate-local-0000011c;1'
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] -- Local/92310042 at originate-local-0000011c;1 Internal Gosub(outgoing-ring-answer,s,1) complete GOSUB_RETVAL=
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] == Spawn extension (loop, s, 6) exited non-zero on 'Surrogate/Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2'
> ...
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] -- Channel Local/92310041 at originate-local-00000118;2 joined 'simple_bridge' basic-bridge <34bf92cb-33be-41d1-b822-c56b79c5ff2d>
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] <--Read on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;2
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] -- Channel Local/92310041 at originate-local-00000118;1 joined 'simple_bridge' basic-bridge <3ce0fb16-2e69-4539-891f-7bbfc10ecb8f>
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: -1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] -- Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;1 joined 'simple_bridge' basic-bridge <3ce0fb16-2e69-4539-891f-7bbfc10ecb8f>
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: -1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] <--Read on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;2
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: -1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] <--Read on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;2
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] <--Read on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;2
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: CONNECTED LINE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 88
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] <--Read on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;2
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] <--Read on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;2
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: CONNECTED LINE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 88
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: -1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] <--Read on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;2
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: CONNECTED LINE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 88
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] <--Read on Channel Local/6*4002702128*92310042 at outgoing-0000011b;2
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] <--Read on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;2
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] <--Read on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;2
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: CONNECTED LINE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 88
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] --> Write on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;1
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] <--Read on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;2
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] <--Read on Channel Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;2
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] FrameType: CONTROL
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] SubClass: SRCCHANGE
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Bytes: 0
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14] Src: NOT PRESENT
> [2022-09-11 19:13:14]
> voip*CLI> group show channels
> Channel Group Category
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 PJSIP/ATAxGrandstream1 deviceinuse
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 1 lineinuse
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 1 oe
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 1 oeall
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 1 oeall
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 1 lineinuseoutboundunanswered
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 1 bridgedcalls
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 looparound_231004tone side
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 looparound_231004 looparound
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 PJSIP/ATAxLB1 deviceinuse
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 6 lineinuse
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 6 oe
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 6 oeall
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 6 oeall
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 6 bridgedcalls
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 looparound_231004 side
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 looparound_231004 looparound
> Local/2310041 at route-0000011a;2 6 lineinuseoutboundanswered
> Local/1*4002702122*92310041 at outgoing-00000117;2 1 lineinuseoutboundanswered
> 19 active channels
> {noformat}
--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.2#6252)
More information about the asterisk-bugs
mailing list