[Asterisk-bsd] Asterisk port and portupgrade

[Ian FREISLICH]

Florian Smeets wrote:
> On 15.06.11 10:07, Ian FREISLICH wrote:
> > Florian Smeets wrote:
> >> On 13.06.11 16:57, Ian FREISLICH wrote:
> >>> I was wondering if anyone else has noticed that when the asterisk
> >>> port is upgraded with portupgrade, the asterisk user is removed
> >>> from the dahdi group and not re-added.  I'll re-check if port
> >>> correctly installs the asterisk user in the dahdi group (I don't
> >>> think it does, but I'm not sure now)
> >>
> >> which asterisk port are you talking about? I just tried it with
> >> net/asterisk and it does work. Before and after the update i have
> >>
> >>    uid=931(asterisk) gid=931(asterisk) groups=931(asterisk),843(dahdi)
> >>
> >> I used portmaster though i do not think this should make a difference.
> >
> > The server in question is 8.2-STABLE compiled on May 2, 2011.  It
> > happened most recently when I manually upgraded from asterisk-1.6
> > to asterisk-1.8.3.  The steps I performed were from an older ports
> > tree:
> >
> > 1. build asterisk-1.8.3
> > 2. pkg_delete asterisk-addons asterisk-1.6
> > 3. install asterisk-1.8.3
> >
> > The dahdi group in /etc/group at this point dropped the asterisk
> > user.  I manually added asterisk to the dahdi group.  Then, I cvsuped
> > and cvs updated the ports tree to latest and did a portupgrade -vf
> > asterisk to upgrade to asterisk-1.8.4.2.  After this completed, I
> > again had to add asterisk to the dahdi group in /etc/group.
> >
> 
> Hi,
> 
> i cannot reproduce this. I just upgraded another server from 1.8.4.2 to 
> 1.8.4.3 and after the upgrade i still have asterisk in the dahdi group:
> 
> flo at tb:~ 37 > id asterisk
> uid=931(asterisk) gid=931(asterisk) groups=931(asterisk),843(dahdi)
> flo at tb:~ 38 > grep dahdi /etc/group
> dahdi:*:843:asterisk
> 
> Can you still reproduce this when upgrading to 1.8.4.3?

I had to downgrade to 1.6 because 1.8 doesn't seem to work with
FreePBX.

It's reproduceable for me in the following way:

[brane] ~ # grep dahdi /etc/group
dahdi:*:843:asterisk
[brane] ~ # portupgrade -rf asterisk16
...
===> Creating users and/or groups.
Using existing group `asterisk'.
Using existing group `dahdi'.
Using existing user `asterisk'.
Setting `asterisk' groups to `www,dahdi,dahdi'.
...
[brane] ~ # grep dahdi /etc/group
dahdi:*:843:

It claims to add asterisk to those groups, but it doesn't actually do it.

The same happens if I perform the following sequence to upgrade:

[brane] /usr/ports/net/asterisk16 # grep dahdi /etc/group
dahdi:*:843:asterisk
[brane] /usr/ports/net/asterisk16 # make
[brane] /usr/ports/net/asterisk16 # make deinstall
[brane] /usr/ports/net/asterisk16 # make install
[brane] /usr/ports/net/asterisk16 # grep dahdi /etc/group
dahdi:*:843:

Ian

-- 
Ian Freislich